THE SUNDAY BRIEF ยท Nยบ 007 ยท THE BIG DECISION

Phillips ยท Rolex 6062 "Time Capsule Stelline" in yellow gold, lot 129.
Last Sunday the Stelline hadn't sold yet. I told you the only comparable was thin and that condition would decide it. It did.
This week: what lot 129 made, how my earlier Geneva calls held up, and a first go at something I'll do after every big sale from now on. One table that tells you how often a house's estimates held.
01 ยท The Stelline
Lot 129 at Phillips was a Rolex 6062 "Time Capsule Stelline" in yellow gold, case 911'113, estimated "in excess of CHF 600,000". Phillips published a Sold For result of CHF 2,334,500.
Put the estimate on the same footing first. With Phillips' published buyer's premium, CHF 600,000 at the hammer is CHF 762,000. The result is about three times that.
The comparable I gave you last week, a different yellow-gold Stelline (case 916'340) sold at Phillips in May 2019 for CHF 548,000, now sits at about a quarter of Sunday's price. The 326% gap between the two results compares two different watches, so it says little about the reference. Phillips sold this one on preservation, and the room paid for it.
For a buyer, the lesson is the one from last week, only louder. On a 6062, condition sets most of the price. If a seller quotes you CHF 2.33 million for an ordinary Stelline, ask which case number he is pricing from.
02 ยท How my Geneva calls held up
I'd rather you hear it from me.
Patek 1436 steel, lot 95. On 1 November I wrote: buy below CHF 2.6m at the hammer. With fees, that's about CHF 3.24m. It sold for CHF 6,267,000, nearly twice my level. Nobody bought it at my price.
Journe Rรฉgence, lot 7. I said wait. It sold for CHF 8,680,500. If you waited, you missed it. I couldn't put a price on it before the sale, and I still can't.
Stelline, lot 129. On 8 November: bid only on condition you've verified yourself. Whoever bought it paid CHF 2,334,500 for that condition.
03 ยท The Allocated Estimate Index
An estimate is the house's opinion. Here is how often the room agreed. For every lot, I take the house's own low and high estimate, add its published buyer's premium so both sides are on the same footing, and compare it with the published result.
Phillips, The Geneva Watch Auction: XXIV, 7 and 8 November
Lots with a range and a published result: 213
Sold above the high estimate: 109 (51%)
Sold within the estimate: 100 (47%)
Sold below the low estimate: 4 (2%)
Median result: 2.1 times the low estimate
Christie's, Rare Watches, 9 November
Lots with a range and a published result: 218
Sold above the high estimate: 76 (35%)
Sold within the estimate: 128 (59%)
Sold below the low estimate: 14 (6%)
Median result: 1.6 times the low estimate
Half of Phillips' lots went past the top of the range. At Christie's, a third. Below-estimate results were rare at both.
In Geneva this week, the low estimate was not a price you could expect to pay. If you set your limit from the estimate, you probably went home with nothing.
The index measures how far below the room the estimates were set, and nothing about how prices moved this year. I'll run it after every major sale, so you can see which house and which season runs hot.
Sotheby's Important Watches sale of 8 and 9 November isn't in this first edition: on its sale page, results are shown only to logged-in visitors.
Zรผrich, briefly
Broad Arrow's Zรผrich sale offered a 2025 911 GT3 Touring as lot 149, estimated CHF 190,000 to 220,000 with a reserve when I read the catalogue on 5 November. It is now listed as Not Sold. A new GT3 with Touring package is CHF 232,700 including VAT on Porsche's Swiss site. The estimate is a hammer figure, before buyer's premium and VAT, so the two prices aren't on the same footing.
ALLOCATED VIEW ยท THREE BUYERS
Bidding at the next Geneva sale. Set your limit from the comparables, not the estimate. This week the low estimate was beaten by a wide margin on most lots.
Offered a Stelline privately. Ask which case number, and ask for the condition report and close photographs. Sunday's price belongs to case 911'113.
Thinking of selling. A week like this one is when a house's low estimate works as cheap advertising for you. It is not a guarantee: Christie's still had 14 lots sell below the low estimate.
VERDICT ยท GENEVA, NOVEMBER 2026 ยท SET YOUR LIMIT FROM COMPARABLES, NOT THE ESTIMATE
Next Sunday: two manual supercars that cost the same money new. Today one is advertised at two to three times the other.
Considering a watch? Reply with the reference and the price you've been quoted. I'll check the available comparables and their limits.
Arnaud
Allocated
SOURCES & METHOD
Results read on each house's own results page on 11 November 2026 and re-checked on 13 November 2026; Broad Arrow estimate read on the lot page on 5 November 2026, before the sale.
Method. Each low and high estimate is a hammer price. I convert it to a buyer's price with the house's published, tiered buyer's premium for that sale (Phillips: 27% up to CHF 1.6m, 21% to CHF 7m, 14.5% above; Christie's: 28% up to CHF 1.6m, 22% to CHF 7m, 15% above), then compare it with the published result ("Sold For" at Phillips, "Price Realised" at Christie's). No hammer price is reconstructed from a result. VAT and other taxes are left out on both sides. Lots estimated "in excess of" a figure are compared with that figure only and left out of the above, within and below counts (three at Phillips, all at or above it). One Phillips lot (189) is marked sold without a published price and is left out. Five Phillips catalogue numbers (124, 131, 146, 210, 221) don't appear on the results page; Phillips doesn't say whether they were withdrawn or unsold.
The Patek 1436 comparison converts my CHF 2.6m hammer level to a buyer's price (about CHF 3,242,000) with the same schedule; Saturday's result is not converted.
Phillips, The Geneva Watch Auction: XXIV, all lots: phillips.com/auction/CH080426/browse
Phillips, lot 129, Rolex 6062 "Time Capsule Stelline", case 911'113: phillips.com/detail/rolex/238061
Phillips, May 2019, lot 71, Rolex 6062 Stelline, case 916'340: phillips.com/detail/rolex/CH080119/71
Phillips, lot 95, Patek Philippe 1436: phillips.com/detail/patek-philippe/237684
Phillips, lot 7, F.P. Journe 212/02R: phillips.com/detail/f.p.-journe/232379
Phillips, Conditions of Sale, Geneva: dist.phillips.com/content/web/docs/forms/Conditions_of_Sale_GVA.pdf
Christie's, Rare Watches Including Watches for ELA, Geneva, 9 November 2026: christies.com/en/auction/auction-31085
Christie's, Conditions of Sale, Geneva, 1 September 2026, section D1: christies.com/pdf/Live/ConditionsOfSale-Geneva-1SEPT2026.pdf
Broad Arrow, The Zรผrich Auction 2026, lot 149: broadarrowauctions.com/vehicles/dg26_r0046/2025-porsche-911-gt3-touring
Porsche Switzerland, 911 GT3 with Touring package, list price including VAT, checked 13 November 2026: porsche.com/swiss/de/models/911/911-gt3-models/911-gt3-touring
What's worth buying. What isn't. The author may own, have owned or trade pieces discussed. Nothing here is financial advice.
Not subscribed yet? Get the brief every Sunday: allocated.club/subscribe